Screens make colour by adding red, green and blue light; presses make it by laying four inks on paper. A file saved in CMYK describes ink, and a browser that expects light has to convert it. The result is often dull or shifted colour, and some systems cannot read such a file at all.
CMYK files usually reach a webshop from print work: a catalogue, a packaging design, an agency export. Several marketplaces state that they do not accept the mode, or warn that it causes errors, and ask for RGB or the sRGB profile. A few specifications written for print and retail suppliers still accept both.
Converting to RGB in an image editor before upload solves the problem, and it is worth comparing the colours afterwards, since strong blues and greens change most. Photos from a phone or camera are RGB from the start, as are images produced for the web.
What the four letters of CMYK stand for
C, M and Y are cyan, magenta and yellow, the three inks that each absorb one part of white light. K stands for key, the black plate to which printers once aligned the others. Black gets its own ink because the three colours together give a muddy dark brown rather than a deep black, and because text and fine lines print sharper in one ink than in three stacked layers.
CMYK is subtractive: paper starts white, and every layer of ink takes light away, so more ink means darker. A screen is additive: it starts black and adds red, green and blue light, so more of each means brighter. This opposite logic is why a file made for one cannot simply be shown on the other.
Why CMYK is not one fixed set of colours
The same CMYK values print differently on coated and uncoated paper, on cardboard, on newsprint and on different presses. Print shops therefore work with profiles that describe their paper and press, and a CMYK file is fully defined only together with such a profile.
Each mode also reaches colours the other cannot. Vivid screen greens, blues and some oranges lie outside what four inks can print, and design programs mark them as out of gamut. A few printed cyans and yellows in turn lie outside sRGB, which is one reason why a conversion from one mode to the other and back does not return the original colours.
When a seller does need CMYK
Hang tags, labels, packaging, printed catalogues, lookbooks and posters go to print. The print shop usually asks for CMYK files made with its own profile, or converts RGB files itself. Asking which of the two it wants before the files are prepared saves a second round of proofs.
A practical arrangement keeps one RGB master of every image and makes print copies from it, never the reverse. The web image is exported from the master in sRGB; the print copy is converted with the printer's profile and checked on screen with a soft proof, a preview that simulates the paper and inks.
CMYK and related colour terms
- sRGB colour space
- sRGB is the colour space that browsers and phones assume, and the one a product image should be in online. A CMYK file meant for a product page is converted to sRGB specifically, not just to RGB in general.
- Colour space
- A colour space is the defined range of colours a file can describe. CMYK is a colour model, and each combination of paper and press has its own CMYK colour space, described by a profile.
- ICC profile
- An ICC profile is the tag inside a file that names its colour space. For a CMYK file it describes a particular press and paper; without it, the same ink values can be read in several ways.
- Adobe RGB
- Adobe RGB is a wider RGB space made with print in mind. It covers more of the colours a press can print than sRGB does, which is why photographers use it for print work, but online it is converted to sRGB just as a CMYK file is.
A CMYK checklist for web and print
- Every image for a product page or a product feed is in RGB with the sRGB profile, including images first made for print.
- Files from a designer, an agency or a supplier were checked for their colour mode before upload, not after an error.
- Strong blues, greens and oranges were compared with the product after any conversion between the two modes.
- Print copies are made from the RGB master with the profile the print shop names, and the master itself stays in RGB.
- Before a print run, a soft proof or a printed proof was checked, since a screen shows light and not ink on paper.
